Thursday, March 19, 2020

Talking My Way Through the Writing Process


If you engaged with me in conversation, it would not take you long to realize that I am a TALKER! I have always had a lot to say, even before my verbal skills had developed, and that has not changed in adulthood. I love conversing with others and discussing ideas. When I get to talking about an interesting clinical case, paper or research idea, I could talk at a rate of “a million miles per minute”, indefinitely.  Not only do I find speaking aloud helps me develop ideas, but my ideas flourish with the live feedback from the other(s) engaged in the discussion. If you observed the inner workings of my mind, you would see that “Kandi Land”, if you will, is generally a lively and vibrant land busy with a steady flight of ideas, tangential thoughts, enthusiasm and curiosity. My inner world is so busy I often wonder, how is it that people feel bored? I am rarely at a loss for words and I could come up with an engaging story about a paperclip on the spot if prompted. However, when I sit down at my computer and open up a word document to start writing academically (if I actually get to that point) it’s like my brain freezes. I feel physically and mentally incapacitated. The best analogy I can use to describe my experience is like the Apple/Mac “spinning pinwheel of death”. With all my ideas and excitement, why do I find it so hard to write? Why is written communication so much more difficult for me than spoken communication?

As a clinical psychologist, I can explain my experience away with clinical jargon about the various regions of my brain involved in language, communication, and my cognitive strengths and weaknesses. Yet a PhD is not needed to understand the essence of my problem, which is that I get overwhelmed by my ideas and fail to organize my thoughts in order to write. Despite my knowledge of the brain and cognitive processes and fully knowing that I need to organize my thought process, I still struggle with academic writer’s block. Here I am two and half years into my career as a clinical faculty member, and I find myself more stuck than ever.  Without the external pressure of deadlines and academic milestones from graduate school, I find myself engaged in nearly every academic activity except writing!

A few weeks ago, I submitted an abstract for a poster presentation at an upcoming conference. Only after I finally submitted the abstract and I was relishing in the relief and sense of freedom, did I realize how remarkably agonizing and painful I made the writing process. Even though I had orally communicated the relevance my research interest, my specific research question, the methods, and scope of the data to be presented in poster form on multiple occasions, the spinning pinwheel of death took over every time I attempted to write the abstract. For over a month I repeatedly avoided, procrastinated, and scared myself out of writing one brief paragraph. As usual, I did not find the motivation and focus to complete the task until the deadline was about to pass. By the time I had finished it I was exhausted, which immediately led to guilt, self-criticism, and shame about how little I accomplished and how much more I should be writing. Of course, this pattern of thinking is the opposite of motivating. I often tell my patients to “focus on the lesson rather than the mistake” and thankfully I decided to take some of my own advice. So, I began reflecting on what has been getting in my way. In fact, I agreed to do this blog post as an attempt to get myself unstuck! Committing to writing this blog post provided me with much needed structure (i.e. clear writing task and a deadline) to kick me into gear and here is what I learned:

Lesson 1: It is helpful (and often necessary) to break things down into smaller tasks, then break them down again. I often get lost in the literature when looking for relevant articles because I find so many areas of my field interesting. Thus, it is not only overwhelming, but unrealistic for me to think that I will successfully (1) identify a journal to submit my (unwritten) article, (2) complete a literature search, (3) read the articles, and (4) start writing my background in one writing session. However, if I’m honest, this is the exact expectation that I typically have in mind when I set out to “work on a paper”, which directly impedes me from actually sitting down to work. Therefore, I revised my plan to (1) identify potential journals and (2) organize the literature I have collected over the past year. Unfortunately, this was still too ambitious and unstructured for me. Three hours later I had narrowed down three potential journals (success), but I had also downloaded more than ten new papers, had countless tabs on my computer screen open, and my kitten had scattered my 20+ articles all over the living room (e.g. less organized than when I started). So, for my next writing session I plan to organize the literature I have already collected in reference list form. Period. After I complete that task, I can move onto developing an outline to guide future writing blocks.

Lesson 2: Use the Pomodoro Technique! Time and time again I come back to this technique. It is a simple and effective time management strategy- set the timer for 25 minutes and work until the timer rings. Set the timer for 5-10 minutes and take a break. Set the timer for another 25 minutes and repeat. 

Lesson 3: To get unstuck, you have to address the unhelpful thoughts, beliefs, and the emotions undermining your efforts.  Mindfulness, as in present awareness without judgment, is a useful strategy to interrupt unhelpful ways of thinking. Kandi-Land is not all sunshine, rainbows and gum drops. Once I started paying attention to the way I talk to myself and my beliefs about writing, it was clear that I am my own worst enemy. I cling to unhelpful and irrational beliefs about the writing process and my own abilities that fuel pervasive self-doubt. I am a perfectionist and overly self-critical. Oh, and surprise, it’s not actually helpful to spend your dedicated writing time berating yourself for all the things you haven’t yet written! To get out of this vicious cycle/toxic way of thinking I found it helpful to take pause and have a mindful moment, which is actually quite simple. All you have to do is bring your attention to the present moment and focus on the live sensations you notice without evaluating your experience. For example, when I caught myself dwelling on the things I haven’t written while I was supposed to be writing this post, I re-directed my attention to where I was sitting, what I could see in front of me, what I heard, etc., and I effectively interrupted the viscous cycle of angst and self-doubt. Though it is important to note that I had repeat this practice over and over again throughout my writing session!

Lesson 4: Lay out a schedule with deadlines for each task. All this reflection made me realize I am also overwhelmed by all the other responsibilities I have in life. Planning and explicitly scheduling time for writing is a tried and true strategy. It worked for me in graduate school so why haven’t I been put this into practice lately? Yes, the internal barriers discussed above have played a major role in deterring me from laying out a schedule, but I have also been very busy balancing my clinical and administrative responsibilities at work with my personal life and health. It’s so easy to lose sight of long-term goals and priorities. So, I have been routinely asking myself questions such as, “Why do I want to write and publish anyways?” to help me regain perspective and sustain motivation to write.

Lesson 5: Talk out loud to get started! I started this post questioning why it is so hard for me to express my thoughts in written form when it’s so easy for me to orally express my thoughts. So, I spent some time exploring the underlying processes of spoken and written communication and felt validated in the difficulties I experience. Specifically, I found it meaningful to consider the contrast between spoken language, which is generally unplanned and consists of incomplete sentences, corrections, and interruptions; and written communication, which is precise, formal, and permanent. Acknowledging the nuanced, yet fundamental differences between modes of communication fostered self-compassion, in terms of appreciating my strengths and to be less punitive toward my perceived shortcomings. And so, in moving forward with writing, the next time I am stuck with the spinning pinwheel of death, I will use voice to text technology to get unstuck (i.e. translate spoken word into written form). Now, it’s time I move forward with implementing this plan!

Kandi Schmidt, PhD

Sunday, March 1, 2020

Perseverance- The struggle is REAL

After receiving a very positive reception of my article, I struggle to keep the momentum going.  This is not my first post about this particular concern, however some things bear repeating, at least for me.  Maintaining momentum following publishing and managing the enduring pressure to produce can be overwhelming.  The potential for rejection following submission only augments this anxiety.  A considerable amount of time has passed, however I have been quite active in my efforts to write.  I have attended Writing Boot Camps, the OpEd project, and continue to participate in our monthly writing group. I have contributed to group articles and agreed to co author a book chapter. I attempt to contribute to any relevant publication undertaking. I am determined to publish for promotion but it seems as though my efforts are insufficient.  I question whether I have the bandwidth or attentional capacity to do all that is required in order to achieve this goal. Academic practitioners (pracademics) in medical settings are called upon to teach, supervise, consult, see patients (not my usual term), and engage in research and publication.  There never seems to be enough time to accomplish everything AND indulge in work-life balance.  Journal submission and promotion deadlines are helpful in keeping me focused and on track, but the stress of it all can be afflictive.

Obviously, I am writing... and writing... and writing even now.  What is helpful to ensure that I stay relatively centered?  At one time, I found writing anything post grad school that was not a note entered into someone's medical record to be utterly daunting.  I obsess over eveything I write to a dysfunctional degree which has hindered my productivity in the past.  Participating in my writing group has aided me by acknowledging the difficulties and complexities of writing in a medical setting.  I am cognizant of the fact that I am not companionless in this predicament.  I have been encouraged and supported in my endeavors.  The group also affords the opportunity and privilege of peer mentoring and review prior to submission. For this I am truly appreciative.

Writing, work and life balance?  Well that is another blog altogether!  I get up EARLY 5 days a week to indulge in some "me" time.  Some refer to this as mindfullness, I call it keeping the chaos at bay! This tends to facilitate personal peace prior to my frequently busy days.  As recommended in writing boot camp, I attempt to manage the drowning feeling associated with the writing process by working on projects for at least 30 minutes per day.  At work this rarely takes place and I regularly strain to find pockets of time for writing when at home.  The positive note is that 30 minutes goes by quite quickly when I can navigate the tumultuous landscape of my life.  It helps to pre plan and do as much as possible beforehand and give others an activity to do that will last for at least 30 minutes! In other words, I contract for 30 minutes of "off duty" time with family, friends, and fur babies.  When the writing is on a deadline and more than 30 minutes is required, I take brain breaks.  I am a gamer so I find it a valuable opportunity to decompress by playing online games.  I am party of a community of fellow gamers that cause me to smile and laugh, when writing does not.  I don't allow myself to get too far from my laptop out of fear that I might not return to my writing if I do!

The moral of the story?  Despite the ambiguity coupled with writing, I have to and will trudge on and hope to love it.....one day.

Erica D. Marshall - Lee, Ph.D.



Talking My Way Through the Writing Process

If you engaged with me in conversation, it would not take you long to realize that I am a TALKER! I have always had a lot to say, even bef...